| Confiscation of Jerusalem
ID Cards Stepped Up
In order to keep step with
the government’s drive to separate “sovereign” Israel from the West Bank,
the Interior Ministry has in recent weeks intensified its efforts to bureaucratically
sever Palestinian Jerusalemites living outside the city. The Interior Ministry
has long been a central tool in Israel’s policy of minimizing the Palestinian
population of Jerusalem. Now, that Prime Minister Rabin is talking “separation”
(apartheid in Afrikaans), the Interior Ministry must set its books straight
and shift out those Palestinians who will maintain their rights to reside
in their capital city from the rest.
The most direct method used
by Interior Ministry workers to cut off the residents is the revocation
of their Jerusalem ID cards. This method is nothing new. Since Israel classifies
Palestinian Jerusalemites as permanent residents, they are subject to Regulation
11 of the Law of Entry to Israel. The regulation stipulates that if permanent
residents are “abroad” (including the West Bank) for seven years or more,
they are liable to lose their residency rights. In the past, the Interior
Ministry sometimes used this regulation to revoke Jerusalem ID cards, but
even people living in Jordan or elsewhere were still able to maintain their
Jerusalem residency by periodic visits to the city.
Now Interior Ministry clerks
demand proof that the person indeed resides in Jerusalem. The burden of
proof continually grows heavier: arnona payments (municipal tax), electricity
bills, registration of children in a Jerusalem school, and so on. If the
proof does not meet the Interior Ministry’s satisfaction, the resident’s
ID card is confiscated.
The Interior Ministry’s
new policy on the issue is still unclear, but recent reports indicate that
they want to define who is a Jerusalem resident and who is not as soon
as possible - on Israel’s terms of course. Newspapers have reported that
the ministry now requires Palestinian Jerusalem residents to renew their
ID cards every two years. In a recent meeting of the coalition of human
rights lawyers and organizations working on the issue of family reunification
and residency rights, it was reported that the village of Dahiat, on the
West Bank side of what Israel currently considers the border of the Jerusalem
municipality, underwent a night of ID card terror in mid-March. Residents
reported that IDF soldiers entered the village, demanding to see their
ID cards. The soldiers then confiscated the ID cards belonging to Jerusalem
permanent residents. They told the residents that if they want their blue
(Israeli) IDs back then they should move to live inside the borders of
Jerusalem, if not they will receive orange (West Bank) ID cards.
Until now members of the
coalition have hesitated taking the issue to the Israeli Supreme Court
for fear of a ruling that will reinforce the soldiers’ orders to the Dahiat
residents - either go to Jerusalem now, or stay out forever. However, one
organization - under pressure from the weight of cases of Jerusalem residents
who have “lost” their ID cards - filed a petition to the court in late
March. In addition the coalition decided to go to the new Interior Minister,
Uzi Baram, and demand a clarification of the ministry’s policy on the issue.
The feeling among the coalition is that it may be possible to bide time
for Jerusalemites living in the West Bank (there are over 50,000 such residents,
plus their family members), but that it will be very difficult for those
living outside the country to hold on their Jerusalem ID cards. Clearly,
though, the issue is a political one, and accordingly a solution will have
to be brought about through political means.
The Interior Ministry’s
measures are clearly intended to define the issue of Jerusalem - and its
residents - before it is due to be negotiated next year. In reaction, some
Jerusalem residents have indeed been moving back into the city. This has
placed even more pressure on the already airtight housing situation in
East Jerusalem - the very reason why many people left the city in the first
place. Others, to guarantee their rights in Jerusalem, have taken Israeli
citizenship - an early victory for Israel even before the issue of the
city is placed on the table. |